An insider told us Einbinder, 31, brought Nathaniel, 38, as her “date” to a friend’s graduation party in Los Angeles over the weekend and that they were “acting like a couple.”
Our source — who provided photos and a video of the pair at the party — said they were “hugging,” “kissing” and “exchanging affection” throughout the night.
The duo looked “pretty comfortable with each other,” according to our informant, who noted that the celebration was an intimate one.
Additionally, we’re told Einbinder referred to Nathaniel as her boyfriend last week during a fan encounter at the Provincetown International Film Festival in Massachusetts.
A spy told us the writer — who lives in New York City — was “incredibly kind” to two fans and agreed to take their picture with Einbinder.
We’re told one of the fans leaned in to ask the “gracious and chill” actress, “Is that your boyfriend?” to which she allegedly replied, “Yeah, kinda.”
It appears the two have been “an item” for at least several weeks.
Deuxmoi reported last month that they were “spotted canoodling in NYC.”
Einbinder made headlines during the 2025 Primetime Emmy Awards for an acceptance speech that was praised by some and slammed by others.
After winning the Emmy for outstanding supporting actress in a comedy series, Einbinder rattled off numerous thank-yous and concluded by shouting out the Philadelphia Eagles, condemning President Trump’s immigration agenda and calling for the end of the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories.
“Go Birds, f–k ICE and free Palestine,” she stated very clearly into the mic before walking away.
Nathaniel was likely among those who appreciated the remarks, as he is best known for his on-the-ground reporting from the occupied West Bank.
Einbinder — who identifies as bisexual — was last publicly linked to comedian Alex Edelman.
